Updated July 15, 2018 7:03 PM PT

Personal Capital Review: Is It Worth It?

This article contains references to products from our partners. We may receive compensation if you apply or shop through links in our content. You help support CreditDonkey by reading our website and using our links. (read more)

Personal Capital offers free tools to track your finances. But is it safe? Read this review for the pros and cons before you sign up.

What is Personal Capital

Personal Capital is an all-in-one financial toolkit. It offers free money management tools, as well as financial advice - for a fee. We'll explain the pros and cons below.

Read on for full reviews of Personal Capital's free AND paid services to determine if they're right for you.

In this article, we'll cover:

PERSONAL CAPITAL'S MONEY MANAGEMENT TOOLS

You can use Personal Capital for free to manage your financial life. You don't have to enroll in the investment service. Even if you only have a credit card and a bank account or two, this service is really useful.

Here are some of the free money management tools Personal Capital offers:

  • See your cash flow: Personal Capital will track your deposits and spending based on your debit and credit card use and ATM cash withdrawals across all your accounts. It's hard and tedious to do this yourself, so with this, you can see just how much of your income you use each month.

  • Track your spending habits: Do you know where your money goes each month? Personal Capital will gather all your transactions in one place, so you can see the exact amount you spend for each merchant and category. If you find that way too much of your income goes to restaurants, then perhaps it's time to eat more at home.

  • Learn your net worth: Your net worth is simply your assets minus your liabilities. Once you have linked all your accounts, Personal Capital will calculate your net worth. It'll also continue to automatically update it based on your ever-changing financial situation (such as investment gains or losses). You'll get a weekly update of your current net worth.

  • Fee analyzer: This is the place where most people lose money without even realizing it. Most investment accounts charge fees, including trade and administrative fees, and banks may even charge you fees for checking and savings accounts.

    A bit like your own private financial detective, Personal Capital tracks fees and shows you where you might be wasting money. You can use this information to call your bank and see if they can reduce the fees or find a better account for your needs.

  • Portfolio performance: The Investment Checkup tool helps you analyze whether your current strategy is meeting your financial goals. Based on your goals and risk tolerance, Personal Capital will advise you if you need to change your allocation (like more bonds and less stocks). It will give you suggestions on how to reduce risk while maintaining performance.

  • Retirement planner: This is one of the most advanced retirement calculators out there. Based on all the accounts you have linked, it will automatically calculate projected income, investments, and Social Security distributions. You can also manually add in big financial events like buying a house, wedding, having a baby, and kids' college expenses. The program will take all this info and come up with a realistic look at what your retirement will look like.

Is it Worth It?

In a word, YES. Personal Capital's free money management tools are some of the best in the industry. While others, such as Mint, offer tools similar to Personal Capital's net worth tracker and spending analysis tools, Personal Capital does it very well - and offers more free tools than that too.

Personal Capital's portfolio performance and fee analysis tools go above and beyond your day-to-day personal finance needs - and they're free.

Why is it worth it? Personal Capital's tools are easy to set up and to use, and they offer real, complete advice with robust tools. You can learn a lot just using their free services.

How does Personal Capital make money? Personal Capital makes money through its paid robo-plus-financial advisor service, which starts at an annual fee of 0.89%. Personal Capital has over 1.6 million users with a total over over $7 Billion assets under management.

Pros and Cons of the Fee-Based Service

PROS:

  • Easy setup
  • No cost to join
  • Robo-advisor, but with real human advisors included
  • Advanced money management tools
  • User-friendly mobile app

CONS:

  • Higher fees than competitor robo-advisors
  • $100,000 minimum; aimed at the affluent
  • No budgeting software

HOW MUCH DOES PERSONAL CAPITAL COST?

Personal Capital's free money management tools are, well, free. But its fee-based advice is aimed towards very high net worth investors. The more you have to invest, the lower the fees. The minimum required for investment services is $100,000.

The annual fee structure for the fee-based service is:

  • 0.89% for the first $1 million
  • 0.79% for $1 million - $3 million
  • 0.69% for $3 million - $5 million
  • 0.59% for $5 million - $10 million
  • 0.49% for over $10 million

These are all-inclusive management fees. This means there are no additional trade commission fees or any other hidden fees. The fees are higher than competitors (like Betterment), but you do get financial advisors to help design a strategy that's best for you.

Tip: Personal Capital has higher fees. For example, if you have $100,000 worth of assets, you would need to pay $890 a year for their management service. In comparison, Betterment's fee of 0.25% (for the basic service) means you'll only pay $250. Even if you choose Betterment's Plus service, it'd still be just $400. More on Personal Capital vs. Betterment later.

Personal Capital's fees are even higher than Vanguard, which has a Personal Advisor service for those with $50,000 or more. The flat rate fee for Vanguard is just 0.30%, or $300 for $100,000 worth of investments.

Personal Capital also offers a set of completely free money management tools (which we'll get into later). Even if you don't want to enroll in the investment service, you can still use Personal Capital for free to manage your financial life. This does not require a $100,000 minimum, or any minimum.

GETTING STARTED

Initial setup is pretty simple. Sign up for a Personal Capital account and link all your external financial accounts. This can include your banks, CDs, trading platforms, etc. Personal Capital is linked to over 12,000 financial institutions, so you should have no problem finding your accounts.

Once you are satisfied that you have linked everything, you can schedule a free consultation. The advisor will go over your current financial state, retirement goals, risk tolerance, and any big financial plans in the future. You'll get a personalized investment strategy based on your goals. If you choose to go ahead with it, you'll open an investment account and fund it.

A WORD ABOUT SECURITY

Is it safe to link all your finances to a company that's only been around a short time? Personal Capital uses a 2-step authentication process and encryption similar to that used by other financial institutions. You'll have to authenticate each device you use via a text or phone call, which should give you some peace of mind if you have multiple devices.

But personal responsibility is also important - always make sure you sign out of any financial-oriented program you use.

Did you know? Personal Capital's CEO is Bill Harris, who was the former CEO of PayPal and Intuit. He also co-founded PassMark Security, which designed the authentication process used by most of the major banks in the U.S. It provides the highest level of security to Internet bankers.

PERSONAL CAPITAL'S ROBO-HYBRID INVESTMENT SERVICE

What sets Personal Capital apart from other robo-advisors is that you get full support from a team of financial advisors.

Most robo-advisors work off of a computer algorithm based on goals and risk tolerance that you input. Personal Capital adds a more human touch. It has a whole committee of advisors and researchers who manage your assets. They take the time to understand your current situation and goals to design a customized strategy.

The level of service you get depends on your balance. Here is what you get at different balance levels (keep in mind that the minimum required for financial advice is $100,000):

  • Up to $200,000: You get access to a financial advisory team, a tax-efficient ETF portfolio, dynamic tactile weighting (asset allocation), 401k advice, 24/7 call-in access, and cash flow and spending insights

  • $200,000 to $1 million: You get everything mentioned above plus 2 dedicated financial advisors, customizable stocks and ETFs, a full financial and retirement plan, college savings and 529 planning, tax loss harvesting, and financial decisions support

  • Over $1 million: You get all of the above plus priority access to advisors, a customized investment portfolio with individual stocks and bonds, private banking services, private equity and hedge fund investment reviews, deferred compensation strategy advice, and estate attorney / CPA collaboration

How it works: During your free consultation, the advisors will come up with a personalized strategy for you. After that, the automated software will do the investing and maintenance of your portfolio. But you still have access to advisors anytime you want if your situation changes. They are there to help and will make any necessary adjustments. Advisors are available by phone, email, and video chat.

PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT

Personal Capital's goal is to yield the highest returns with the least risk. Some of the features it has include:

  • Diversified portfolio: Like most robo-advisors, Personal Capital invests your assets in ETFs, because they tend to be cheap. Your portfolio is built to be globally diversified. It will typically include U.S. stocks and bonds, international stocks and bonds, and cash. A financial advisor works with you to identity the optimal investments for your goals.

  • Disciplined rebalancing: Once you have an investment strategy, it may drift over time, since investments increase (or shrink) at different rates. For example, let's say you wanted 50% stocks, but after a period of time, your assets are now 60% stocks. When this happens, your portfolio may no longer be at the correct risk level for your goals. Personal Capital reviews your portfolio daily and automatically rebalances it whenever it identifies an issue.

  • Optimal tax strategy: Personal Capital helps reduce your taxes with a strategy called Tax Loss Harvesting, which takes tax deductions on your losses to offset your capital gains. And it'll automatically place high-yield stocks into accounts with tax breaks (like IRAs). This is a powerful feature for people with multiple investment accounts. Note that this is only available for those with over $200,000 invested, though.

APP

The Personal Capital app is available for both Android and Apple devices. Like the computer software's easy-to-read platform, the app breaks down your assets, liabilities, investments, credit card debt, mortgages, and any other financial information in a mobile-friendly manner. You can also access your info via a date range (back to the prior year), read tips and research online, or contact your financial advisor.

The app is easy to use at a glance, and even changes colors (green for assets, red for liabilities) as you scroll to readily point out what you own and owe.

How It Compares

PERSONAL CAPITAL VS. BETTERMENT

Betterment is one of the most popular robo-advisors out there right now. It has a much lower fee structure than Personal Capital, so beginners may feel more comfortable with that. The annual fee for the basic service is just 0.25%. Plus, there is no account minimum, whereas Personal Capital's minimum is $100,000.

However, because of the low fee, Betterment is truly just a robo-advisor. The software invests for you based on your age, goals, and risk tolerance. Low net worth investors do not get any kind of real human financial advisor services. So you are basically completely trusting a computer to correctly design and allocate your investment strategy.

If you have a balance of $100,000 or more, you'll upgrade to the Premium service. You get unlimited access to certified financial planners. They can provide in-depth advice on your other investments outside of Betterment and financial guidance on big life events. This fee is 0.40%, which is lower than Personal Capital's fee of 0.89%, but you'll get more personalized service with Personal Capital.

Betterment does not have such advanced money management tools. We do like its SmartDeposit feature though, which automatically sends money to Betterment when your bank account exceeds a certain balance. This is an easy way to make sure you're investing your extra cash.

While Betterment does not have Personal Capital's money management tools, you can still use Personal Capital's tools for free.

 

Personal Capital

Betterment

 

Benefits and Features

Annual Fee0.89% for first $1 million, 0.79% for first $3 million, next $2 million 0.69%, next $5 million, 0.59%, and 0.49% over $10 million0.25% for accounts under $100,000; 0.40% for accounts $100,000+
Minimum Deposit
$100,000
$0
Phone Support
Yes
Yes
Live Chat Support
No
No
Email Support
Yes
Yes
Human Advisors
Yes
Yes
Assets Under Management
$6.5 Billion
$10 Billion
Tax Loss Harvesting
Yes
Yes
Goal Tracker
Yes
Yes
Automatic Deposits
Yes
Yes
Online Platform
Yes
Yes
iPhone App
Yes
Yes
Android App
Yes
Yes
Single Stock Diversification
Yes
No
Fractional Shares
No
Yes
Taxable Accounts
Yes
Yes
401k Plans
Yes
Yes
IRA Accounts
Yes
Yes
Roth IRA Accounts
Yes
Yes
SEP IRA Accounts
Yes
Yes
Trust Accounts
Yes
Yes
529 Plans
Yes
No
Annual Fee
Minimum Deposit
Human Advisors
Customer Service

Personal Capital: Pricing information from published website as of 04/04/2018

Betterment: Pricing information from published website as of 04/04/2018

PERSONAL CAPITAL VS MINT

Another user-friendly financial assessment program is Intuit's Mint. This popular software is also free and operates similarly to Personal Capital's money management service. But unlike Personal Capital, Mint is aimed at more of a mass market and people who are just starting out, rather than high net worth investors. Mint is also a free service, so this comparison is against Personal Capital's free money management tools.

Mint focuses more on your everyday spending and budgeting than it does your future income. It might be a better choice for those who just want to see their financial life all in one place. There's no focus on investment strategy. Mint is simpler and doesn't flash a neon sign about what you're worth, like Personal Capital does (perhaps Mint is really for the less secure among us).

But Personal Capital has proven to be more dependable when it comes to interfacing with your accounts, syncing them, and calculating the data quicker. Both platforms are strong when it comes to giving you a clear view of your financial life, so it's certainly worth trying both out and seeing which one suits your needs best.

Personal Capital vs Quicken: Quicken is one of the first-ever personal finance tools -- it came out in the 1980s -- and it still offers budget trackers. However, almost nothing from Quicken is free, except for a very simple, one-time-use budget calculator. In other words, you're not going to be able to see all of your accounts in one place, analyze your cash flow, or get retirement advice from Quicken without shelling out.

Personal Capital vs Robinhood

Rohinhood is a trading app that offers free trades. You can trade stocks, options, and ETFs with zero commissions. The only account option is a taxable brokerage account. There is no account minimum to get started. So it's great for small investors or frequent traders to trade without losing a bunch of money on fees.

Robinhood is not a robo-advisor. You're responsible for selecting investments and trading yourself. The platform is very basic. It's lacking in research and tools, so you need to be comfortable researching yourself. If you're not, then you may feel it's better to pay a small fee to use a robo-advisor.

BOTTOM LINE

Personal Capital aims to be different by providing excellent wealth management tools, a robo-investment platform, and real human financial advisors.

You can use Personal Capital's money management tools at no cost. These are some of the most advanced tools on the market. It doesn't hurt to sign up for the free account to get a handle on your financial life.

But if you want to enroll in the investment service, the fees are much higher than other robo-advisors. You do get personalized service from financial advisors, which is supposed to justify the cost. But beginners with not too much to invest may still find it high. If you have a LOT to invest (as in millions), the fees get lower and it may be a good value for the level of service.

Cynthia Cohen is a retail analyst at CreditDonkey, a stock broker comparison and financial education website. Write to Cynthia Cohen at cynthia@creditdonkey.com. Our data-driven analysis has been recognized by major news outlets across the country and has helped investors make savvy financial and lifestyle decisions. (read more)

Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are those of the author's alone. Please support CreditDonkey on our mission to help you make savvy financial decisions. Our free online service is made possible through financial relationships with some of the products and services mentioned on this site. We may receive compensation if you shop through links in our content.

More from CreditDonkey:

How to Invest Money

How to Invest Money


Best Roth IRA Providers


Best Online Savings Account

More Articles in Reviews

Next Page:

    Personal Capital

    Get Started with Personal Capital


Leave a comment about Personal Capital Review: Is It Worth It?

Name
Email (won't be published)


July
06
2018

Best Robo Advisor

The best robo-advisor offers low management fees, low minimum investment requirements, and daily account monitoring. Read this list of top robo advisors before you invest.

    Average Savings by Age

    More than half of Americans do not have any retirement savings. Of those who do, the average saved is $60,000.

    Average Utility Bills Will Shock You

    You pay an average of $2,200 per year for your utilities. $1,200 of that money is for electricity alone. Just where else is your money going?

    How Much to Contribute to 401k

    You know you should save money for retirement. But how much should you save and where should you save it?
More Articles in Investing Reviews






About CreditDonkey®
CreditDonkey is a stock broker comparison website. We publish data-driven analysis to help you save money & make savvy financial decisions.

Editorial Note: Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed on this page are those of the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

†Advertiser Disclosure: Many of the card offers that appear on this site are from companies from which CreditDonkey receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). CreditDonkey does not include all companies or all offers that may be available in the marketplace.

*See the card issuer's online application for details about terms and conditions. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. However, all information is presented without warranty. When you click on the "Apply Now" button you can review the terms and conditions on the card issuer's website.

CreditDonkey does not know your individual circumstances and provides information for general educational purposes only. CreditDonkey is not a substitute for, and should not be used as, professional legal, credit or financial advice. You should consult your own professional advisors for such advice.