February 14, 2020

Best Mattress for the Money

Read more about Mattress
This article contains references to products from our partners. We may receive compensation if you apply or shop through links in our content. You help support CreditDonkey by reading our website and using our links. (read more)

You could spend thousands of dollars on a mattress only to find that it lacks in quality. Don't let the price tag steer you wrong. Instead, you need to look at a mattress' features and see how they meet your needs.

© CreditDonkey

Below we discuss the best mattress for the money in each top category. Explore your options and see how they meet your needs.

Best Mattress for the Money Overall: Amerisleep AS3

The Amerisleep AS3 offers the combination of comfort and support that most sleepers need. Combo sleepers especially love this bed because it supports any sleeping position comfortably.

Made with soft, responsive foam, the bed makes you feel as if you're sleeping on a cloud. The AS3 offers a medium firmness that is great for side and combo sleepers. It evenly distributes weight and provides pressure-point relief to ensure sleepers don't wake up with aches and pains.

The Amerisleep AS3 features:

  • Bio-Core foam support base, which is eco-friendly and durable

  • Soft, but responsive transition layer that feels great on pressure points

  • Layer of breathable memory foam that doesn't trap heat

  • Celliant Cover to increase circulation and keep you cool

  • Foam that bounces back (no "stuck" feeling)

  • 100-night trial and 20-year warranty

Which Is Better: Innerspring or Memory Foam Mattresses?
There is no right or wrong when it comes to choosing memory foam or innerspring. Each type has its pros and cons, just as each person has his or her own preferences. Innerspring mattresses tend to be firmer and less cushiony, whereas memory foam tends to be much more conforming and cushioning. If you aren't sure, a hybrid combines the best of both worlds.

Best Memory Foam Mattress for the Money: Loom & Leaf

Memory foam has a bad reputation. Why? Low-quality memory foam beds trap heat and make you feel stuck on the mattress. The Loom & Leaf Memory Foam Mattress puts these worries to rest.

L&L uses high-density 5-pound memory foam made in the United States. The luxurious foam has the perfect amount of bounce and doesn't trap heat. It even works for back sleepers or "hot" sleepers.

Made with eco-friendly materials, the L&L is available in two options: relaxed firm and firm. Most people choose relaxed firm, saving the firm for back and stomach sleepers.

Loom & Leaf Mattress features:

  • Eco-friendly foam with no harmful odors

  • 6-inch high-density foam core that provides a base for additional supportive layers

  • 2-inch transition pad that to provide support without motion transfer issues or feeling stuck

  • 3-inch layer of high-density foam and cooling gel to regulate temperatures

  • Organic cotton cover combined with 5/8-inch foam and natural flame retardant materials

  • 120-night trial and 15-year warranty

Is a memory foam Mattress worth it?
They may cost a little more, but buying a high-quality memory foam mattress can provide you with the comfort and support you need. Make sure you choose your memory foam mattress wisely, though. Watch out for off-gassing, a lack of firm support, and the use of cheap foam that makes you feel stuck.

Best Hybrid Mattress for the Money: Brooklyn Signature Hybrid

Hybrid mattresses combine the benefits of innerspring and foam. The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid comes in three firmness levels, making it a great bed for any sleep position.

Side sleepers prefer the soft version, the medium option helps combo and stomach sleepers, and firm is mainly for stomach or back sleepers. Made with high-quality springs and dense foam, the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid offers the benefits of two types of mattresses in one.

The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid features:

  • 6-inch base with 952 individual coils to limit motion transfer and provide support

  • 1-inch foam base beneath the coil layer for stability and durability

  • 2-inch layer of transitional foam for extended support and pressure-point relief

  • 2-inch top layer of TitanFlex foam for responsiveness and comfort

  • TitaniumGel-infused foam helps wick away body moisture and heat

  • 120-night trial and 10-year warranty

How Long Will a Hybrid Mattress Last?
With proper care and use, a hybrid mattress may last an average of 10 years. Of course, the quality of the mattress' material will determine the lifespan of your particular mattress.

Best Innerspring Mattress for the Money: Saatva Classic

Today, traditional innerspring beds are hard to come by. No one wants to sleep on just innersprings. Saatva takes the traditional innerspring bed, combines it with premium foam, and delivers a firm mattress that satisfies people who need a firm sleeping surface.

You get the traditional coil-on-coil construction with layers of supportive foam to provide the comfort, cradling, and support that back sleepers and foam mattress lovers need.

The Saatva Classic Mattress is available in three firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. It features:

  • Base of 884 13-gauge coils that provide support and long-lasting durability

  • Additional layer of 416 individually wrapped 14.5-gauge coils that respond to your movements, but limit motion transfer

  • Dual-edge support system for reinforced edges

  • Lumbar zone that supports proper spinal alignment

  • Euro pillow top, which is the memory foam comfort layer on top of the coils

  • 120-night trial period and 15-year warranty

How long do innerspring mattresses last?
On average, expect between 7 and 10 years from your innerspring mattress. Of course, the longevity of your bed depends on its quality and the care you give it. If you flip your innerspring mattress regularly and deep clean it at least twice a year, you should get at least seven years out of it. Overuse, not flipping the mattress, or excessive weight in one area can decrease the lifespan of any mattress, including the innerspring.

Best Latex Mattress for the Money: Awara

If you prefer the feeling of latex over memory foam, consider the Awara mattress. You get the stability of innerspring construction and the comfort and support that natural latex provides. Latex also provides the perfect amount of bounce that resists that stuck feeling that memory foam creates.

The Awara mattress contains natural and organic materials to keep you healthy. And its construction provides spinal alignment, full body support, and just enough bounce to make it the perfect mattress for any sleep position.

The Awara features:

  • 9-inch base layer of individually wrapped coils to distribute weight evenly and eliminate motion transfer

  • 4-inch layer of Rainforest Alliance Certified latex to provide just enough resistance for pressure-point relief

  • Breathable organic wool cover to regulate temperature

  • Medium-plush firmness to supports any sleep position, especially combo sleepers

  • 365-night trial and a Forever warranty

Is a latex mattress better than memory foam?
Latex and memory foam are both supportive mattress materials, but they offer different features. Memory foam is more contouring and cushioning, whereas latex is bouncier and offers less compression. People who worry about being stuck in memory foam often prefer the bounciness of latex. But people who love body contouring prefer memory foam over latex.

Best Organic Mattress for the Money: Avocado

Shopping for an organic mattress can be tricky. Unless the mattress is GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) or GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard), it may not be truly organic. The Avocado mattress contains GOLS-certified latex, GOTS organic wool, and cotton.

The Avocado mattress contains no harmful chemicals, materials, or even fire retardants. The bed is available in an 11-inch and 13-inch mattress. The 13-inch mattress has a 2-inch pillow top cover that enhances the comfort for side and combo sleepers.

The Avocado Mattress features:

  • Durable latex for support, long-lasting durability, and temperature regulation

  • Organic wool construction to wick away body moisture and heat

  • 1,414 steel coils for support and limited motion transfer

  • Five ergonomic zones to comfort problem areas, such as your lower back

  • Reinforced perimeter for maximum edge support

  • 1-year trial and 25-year warranty

Best Mattress for the Money for Side Sleepers: Leesa Hybrid

Side sleepers need a bit more comfort and cradling than any other position sleeper. The Leesa Hybrid provides the perfect amount of body contouring and pressure-point relief for comfort all night long.

With superior edge support, the Leesa is a great mattress for couples who need extra space without the worry of sagging or falling off the bed. Made of durable springs and high-density memory foam, side sleepers enjoy a restful and painless night's sleep on the Leesa mattress.

The Leesa Hybrid Mattress features:

  • Base layer of 1,000-pocketed springs for stability and durability

  • Recovery layer of memory foam for pressure-point relief and body contouring

  • Comfort layer of perforated foam for maximum breathability

  • A soft hybrid cover for even more pressure-point relief and comfort

  • Eco-friendly CertiPUR-US-certified foam

  • 100-day free trial and a 10-year warranty

Best Mattress for the Money for Stomach Sleepers: DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid

Stomach sleepers need proper spine alignment, temperature control, and pressure-point relief. That's a tall order to fill, but the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid mattress does it well.

A combination of pocketed innerspring coils and multiple layers of comfortable foam, the DreamCloud provides the supportive, yet comfortable surface stomach sleepers need.

DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress features:

  • Pocketed innerspring coils for mattress' breathability and limited motion transfer

  • Superior edge support

  • Base support layer that helps stabilize the innerspring layer

  • Plush support layer that cradles the body for ultimate comfort

  • Gel-infused memory foam to wick away moisture and body heat

  • 365-night trial and lifetime warranty

Best Mattress for the Money for Back Sleepers: Allswell Luxe Hybrid

Back sleepers may think they need a stiff-as-a-board firm mattress. But this can lead to aching joints and pressure points. Instead, you need "just right" firmness that aligns your spine while providing the perfect amount of comfort.

The Allswell Luxe Hybrid Mattress does all of this and more. This firm, but comfortable mattress provides everything back sleepers need at an incredible price. It offers:

  • Layer of individually wrapped coils to help with spinal alignment

  • 1-inch layer of dense memory foam for comfort and support

  • 2-inch layer of copper-infused foam to regulate temperature and provide pressure-point relief

  • Cover infused with cooling gel for more temperature regulation

  • Superior edge support

  • 100-night trial and 10-year warranty

Best Mattress for the Money to Stay Cool: Layla

If you get hot at night, it can make sleeping difficult. The Layla mattress is a unique mattress that provides cool comfort that suits any sleep position.

One of the few remaining flippable mattresses, the Layla has a soft and a firm side, making it a perfect mattress for any sleep position. The Layla mattress has none of the flaws of a typical memory foam mattress.

It offers:

  • A cooling cover

  • 1-inch layer of copper-infused memory foam for support and temperature regulation

  • 4-inch support core to minimize motion transfer

  • 2-inch layer of breathable memory foam to wick away heat and moisture

  • 3-inch layer of copper memory foam for deep compression support and temperature regulation

  • 120-night free trial and lifetime limited warranty

Best Mattress for the Money for Pressure-Point Relief: WinkBed Hybrid

Pressure-point pain makes it hard to sleep. A too-firm mattress can make the pain worse, while a too-soft one won't provide the necessary spinal support. The WinkBed Hybrid provides the best of both worlds with supportive innerspring construction combined with specialty foam for the ultimate pressure-point relief.

The WinkBed Hybrid Mattress offers:

  • 3-step back relief system that aligns your spine while relieving pressure points

  • Deep support innersprings to limit motion transfer

  • Tencel cover that helps keep you cool and the mattress clean

  • Lifetime Durability System that prevents sagging, which can cause pressure-point pain

  • Compression resistance to support your joints

  • 120-night trial and lifetime warranty

How to Find the Best Bed for the Money

Whether you spend a few hundred or a few thousand dollars on a mattress, there's one common denominator: You want the most value for your money.

So what should you look for in a mattress? Consider the following:

  • Great Edge Support
    Whether you sit on the edge of your bed or you share a mattress with someone, edge support is crucial. It gives you more supportive space on the bed. Not every mattress has great edge support. Pay close attention to foam and latex mattresses, as they often lack in this department. You want reinforced edges for maximum support and mattress versatility.

  • Little Motion Transfer
    No one wants to feel like they're on the Titanic when they sleep with a partner. A quality mattress will absorb movement rather than transfer it to you. Know how a mattress absorbs the motion and its effectiveness. Any bed can have large amounts of motion transfer, but innerspring mattresses often struggle the most.

  • Good Support
    Think about your body and where it hurts. Do you have pressure-point pain? Does your back feel out of alignment? Do you wake with joint pain? You need a mattress that cradles your pressure points, supports key zones like your lower back and hips, and provides adequate spinal alignment.

  • Temperature Regulation
    Your body temperature naturally decreases when you sleep. But if that heat has nowhere to go, it transfers right back to you. This causes overheating and even night sweats. Look for a mattress that wicks body heat and moisture away rather than trapping it, which will make you overheat while you sleep.

  • Sleep Position
    Many mattresses today support any sleeping position. But pay close attention, especially if you are a side or back sleeper. Your sleep position creates the need for certain features, such as pressure-point relief for side sleepers and a firm surface for back sleepers.

Bottom Line

Just because a mattress is expensive doesn't make it great, just as a cheap mattress isn't necessarily bad. Make sure you understand the qualities of a mattress before buying it. Look at the details and determine its firmness level, materials, and features before choosing your next mattress.

Note: This website is made possible through financial relationships with some of the products and services mentioned on this site. We may receive compensation if you shop through links in our content. You do not have to use our links, but you help support CreditDonkey if you do.

More from CreditDonkey:

Best Cheap Mattress

Best Mattress for Side Sleepers

Best Mattress in a Box

Best Air Mattress

Air mattresses are convenient. But not all are comfortable. Here are the top beds you can use every day that won't quickly lose air.

Leave a comment about Best Mattress for the Money?

Email (won't be published)

What to Look for in a Mattress

Better sleep is a new mattress away. But which type is best? And how much should it cost? Find out with this mattress buying guide.

About CreditDonkey®
CreditDonkey is a mattress comparison website. We publish data-driven analysis to help you save money & make savvy decisions.

Editorial Note: Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed on this page are those of the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

†Advertiser Disclosure: Many of the offers that appear on this site are from companies from which CreditDonkey receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). CreditDonkey does not include all companies or all offers that may be available in the marketplace.

*See the card issuer's online application for details about terms and conditions. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. However, all information is presented without warranty. When you click on the "Apply Now" button you can review the terms and conditions on the card issuer's website.

CreditDonkey does not know your individual circumstances and provides information for general educational purposes only. CreditDonkey is not a substitute for, and should not be used as, professional legal, credit or financial advice. You should consult your own professional advisors for such advice.