February 5, 2024

Credit Karma Alternatives

Read more about Credit Karma
Ad Disclosure: This article contains references to products from our partners. We may receive compensation if you apply or shop through links in our content. You help support CreditDonkey by using our links. (read more)

Searching for credit monitoring tools like Credit Karma? Browse these alternatives and their features. Some of them are free.

What should I use instead of Credit Karma?
Here are other alternatives you can try instead of Credit Karma:
  1. Experian: Best Overall
  2. myFICO: Best for FICO Tracking
  3. CreditWise: Best Free Plan
  4. Credit Sesame: Most Similar App
  5. Aura: Best for Families
  6. ID Watchdog: Best Insurance Coverage
  7. Identity Guard: Best Discounts
  8. Identityforce Ultrasecure+Credit: Best for 3-Bureau Monitoring

Credit Karma gives you free credit reports and allows you to track your credit score for free. You also get curated credit card and loan recommendations based on your credit profile.

However, Credit Karma displays ads in the app (which can be annoying) and lacks crucial features to help protect your credit.

So, it's a good thing there are other credit monitoring apps to choose from. In this guide, you'll find the paid and free alternatives you can try. Read on.

8 Best Credit Karma Alternatives

For each alternative, it's best to consider the pricing and features, pros and cons, and how it compares to Credit Karma.

Experian: Best Overall

Experian is one of the three main credit bureaus, and it offers its own credit monitoring service. Regardless of your plan, you can get identity theft monitoring services such as dark web surveillance and privacy scans.

With paid plans, however, you get more features like alerts for SSN traces, financial account takeovers, and social network monitoring.

Paid plans also have a $1 million ID theft insurance. Plus, you can lock your Experian credit report to block unauthorized access to your credit profile.

Pros + Cons:

  • Monitors FICO Score
  • Improve credit score with Experian Boost
  • Recommendations for credit cards and loans
  • Can be costly
  • Limited customer service hours
  • Free plan only covers one credit bureau

Pricing & Features:[1]

FREEPREMIUM
Price$0$24.99/mo
Experian credit report and credit score
3-bureau credit report and credit scoreQuarterly
Credit monitoringExperian onlyEquifax, Experian, and TransUnion
Identity theft monitoring
$1 million identity theft insurance

Experian also offers a Family plan that includes all Premium plan features for 1 additional adult and up to 10 children for identity monitoring. The Family plan costs $34.99 per month.

Credit Karma vs. Experian:
Credit Karma and Experian offer personalized recommendations for loans and credit cards.

However, Experian provides more value for keeping track of credit scores, having extensive credit monitoring features, and securing your credit and identity.

That said, you can pair Credit Karma with Experian's free plan. That way, you can get copies of your Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion reports for free.

myFICO: Best for FICO Tracking

myFICO offers credit monitoring features tailored for tracking your FICO Score—the most common credit score used by lenders.

This can be a huge advantage since over 90% of lenders use FICO Score to assess your creditworthiness. It's what they use to understand your credit risk and make lending decisions.[2]

In addition to tracking your FICO score, paid plans include $1 million in identity theft insurance and identity theft restoration. So you get extra protection against fraudulent activities that can drag down your score.

Pros + Cons:

  • Monitors FICO Score
  • Cancel anytime without fees
  • Educational resources
  • Provides scores for auto loans, mortgages, credit cards, and others
  • Pricey
  • No family plans
  • Free plan doesn't cover all three credit bureaus

Pricing & Features:[3][4]

FREEBASICADVANCEDPREMIER
Price$0$19.95$29.95/mo$39.95/mo
3-bureau coverageEquifax onlyExperian only
FICO ScoreMonthlyMonthlyEvery 3 monthsMonthly
Credit reportMonthlyMonthlyEvery 3 monthsMonthly
$1 million identity theft insurance
Identity theft restoration
Identity theft monitoring

Credit Karma vs. myFICO:
myFICO beats Credit Karma in credit report access and credit score accuracy. It's the better option if you don't mind the hefty price tag. It's also the ideal option if you want to monitor your credit score before applying for loans, mortgages, and credit cards.

Creditwise: Best Free Plan

Capital One's CreditWise offers free credit monitoring for TransUnion and Experian. You can get alerts and notifications for real-time changes in your credit report.

In addition, CreditWise features limited identity theft monitoring with dark web alerts for your account numbers, login credentials, or SSN. You'll know if your data is floating on the dark web.

And if you're trying to maintain good credit? You can access the CreditWise simulator to know the impact of your financial decisions on your current credit. Credit Wise also provides suggestions to help you improve your score.

Pros + Cons:

  • Free credit monitoring feature
  • Don't need to be a Capital One customer to sign up
  • Mobile apps are protected with biometrics and two-factor authentication
  • Doesn't show FICO Scores
  • Limited features
  • Credit report and credit score are limited to TransUnion profile only

Pricing & Features:[5]

FREE
Price$0
Credit reportsTransUnion only
Credit scoreDaily
Dark web alerts
Credit simulator

Credit Karma vs. CreditWise:
CreditWise is a good alternative if you want a simple credit monitoring tool. It's also a good addition if you use Capital One products, since you can access CreditWise within the Capital One app.

Credit Sesame: Most Similar App

Credit Sesame works most similary to Credit Karma. It features basic credit monitoring for TransUnion for free. Plus, it recommends loans, insurance, and credit cards based on your credit profile.

You can keep track of changes to your credit in the Credit Sesame app. In this app, you'll also get real-time alerts for new accounts, account closures, and account charge-offs.

Pros + Cons:

  • Provides suggestions for improving your credit
  • Daily credit score updates
  • Offers credit builder options (for a fee)
  • Monitors VantageScore only
  • Free plan only covers one credit bureau (TransUnion)

Pricing & Features:[6][7]

FREE
Price$0
Credit reportsTransUnion only
Credit scoreDaily
Credit report breakdown
Credit builder option

Credit Sesame's basic account is free but they do have premium subscription options if you want monthly access to your full credit reports from the three major bureaus.

Credit Karma vs Credit Sesame:
You can consider Credit Sesame to be the most similar app to Credit Karma. If you want to try another app that works practically the same way as Credit Karma, try Credit Sesame.

Aura: Best For Families

Aura lets you track real-time changes to your Equifax, TransUnion, and Experian credit reports, with options to lock your Experian file.

In addition, you can get identity theft insurance of $1 million per adult (up to 5 adults in the Family plan). You can also monitor and protect the identity of unlimited kids with SSN alerts, 3-bureau credit freeze, and sex offender geo alerts.

Plans also include VantageScore tracking, where you can get monthly credit scores within the app.

Pros + Cons:

  • Cancel anytime with no fees
  • 60-day money-back guarantee (annual plans)
  • Save up to 75% for the Family plan (annual payment)
  • No free plan
  • Monitors VantageScore only
  • Insurance doesn't cover kids in the Family plan

Pricing & Features:[8]

INDIVIDUALCOUPLESFAMILY
Price$15/mo$29/mo$50/mo
3-bureau credit monitoring
Credit score trackerMonthlyMonthlyMonthly
Identity theft monitoring
$1 million ID theft insurance
Child identity monitoring and protection

Credit Karma vs. Aura:
Aura works best for big families who want to track and keep their credit safe. You get access to features for the online security of your children. You can enroll more members in the Family plan, unlike Credit Karma which works for one user only.

ID Watchdog: Best Insurance Coverage

ID Watchdog comes from Equifax. And all its plans include basic features like Equifax monitoring, credit freeze assistance, and data breach notifications.

Compared to other apps, ID Watchdog also offers more extensive insurance coverage. You're covered with $1 million identity theft insurance to help you recover from fraudulent transactions.

In addition, ID Watchdog offers a 401(k)/HSA reimbursement. You can get up to $1 million in reimbursement for unauthorized transfers from your retirement and health savings accounts.

Pros + Cons:

  • Cancel anytime with no fees
  • Get two months free if you pay annually
  • Can refund unused months (annual payments)
  • Can be expensive
  • Monitors VantageScore only
  • Limited identity theft protection (Select plans)

Pricing & Features:[9]

SELECTPREMIUM
Price$14.95/mo (Individual);
$23.95/mo (Family)
$21.95/mo (Individual);
$34.95/mo (Family)
Credit Report MonitoringEquifax onlyEquifax, Experian, and TransUnion
Equifax VantageScoreMonthlyDaily
Credit report lock
Identity theft monitoring
$1 million identity theft insurance
401(k)/HSA stolen funds reimbursement

You can add up to 2 adults and 4 children with a Family plan. Identity theft monitoring features are mostly available in the Premium plan.

Credit Karma vs. ID Watchdog:
ID Watchdog is worth a try if you prefer extended protection offered by insurance, which is something Credit Karma does not offer. You can get the most value with a Premium plan paid annually, giving you two types of insurance.

Identity Guard: Best Discounts

Identity Guard offers the most affordable plans for individuals and families. Family plans include up to 5 adults and unlimited kids. You can save more and get a 60-day money-back guarantee if you select annual payment.

Identity Guard focuses on identity theft monitoring. Regardless of your plan, you'll get dark breach alerts, dark web monitoring, and high-risk transaction monitoring features.

Pros + Cons:

  • 60-day money-back guarantee (annual plans)
  • 24/7 support and fraud remediation
  • Product of Aura (reputable credit monitoring service)
  • Costly monthly payments
  • You can only view your VantageScore

Pricing & Features:[10]

TOTALULTRA
Price$19.99/mo (Individual);
$29.99/mo (Family)
$29.99/mo (Individual);
$39.99/mo (Family)
3-bureau credit monitoring
Monthly credit score
3-bureau credit reportsAnnual only
Experian credit lock
Identity theft monitoring
$1 million identity theft insurance

Credit Karma vs. Identity Guard:
Credit Karma offers a free plan that does not include extensive identity theft protection. However, Identity Guard offers these paid features with discounts. Identity Guard may be an affordable option if you're in it for the long term.

Identityforce Ultrasecure+Credit: Best 3-Bureau Monitoring

IdentityForce is a credit monitoring service of TransUnion. Its most expensive plan, the UltraSecure+Credit, gets you your reports, credit scores, and credit monitoring for the three credit bureaus.

You also get a full suite of identity theft protection, like advanced fraud monitoring. Plus, you'll get real-time alerts when banks and lenders request your credit report.

You can also monitor change of address, unauthorized use of your name in court records, and dark web monitoring and analysis to prevent unwanted use of your info online.

Pros + Cons:

  • Comprehensive credit monitoring features
  • Affordable premium plan
  • Get two months free if you pay annually
  • Monitors VantageScore only
  • No family plans
  • Several identity theft monitoring features may not be as valuable

Pricing & Features:[11]

ULTRASECURE+CREDIT
Price$23.99/mo
3-bureau credit monitoring
3-bureau credit reports
3-bureau credit score
Identity theft monitoring
$1 million identity theft insurance

Credit Karma vs IdentityForce UltraSecure+Credit:
The UltraSecure+Credit mostly features identity theft protection, while these features are absent in Credit Karma. It can be a better paid option if you want to protect your identity and credit, and maximize paid credit monitoring features.

Now that you know the best alternatives, here's a refresher on what Credit Karma offers to compare.

What Is Credit Karma?

Credit Karma is one of the most popular credit monitoring tools available. You don't even need to pay anything to start.

With Credit Karma, you can:

  • Get weekly credit reports for TransUnion and Equifax
  • View your VantageScore
  • Get notifications for changes in your credit reports
  • Track suspicious or fraudulent activities to your credit
  • Improve credit with the credit builder
  • See your likelihood of getting approved for loans and credit cards

Credit Karma even provides personalized offers from lenders and credit card issuers based on your credit profile.

However, Credit Karma falls short of other essential features for keeping your credit profile safe. For this reason, you may opt for one of its alternatives.

Note that Credit Karma gets paid if you get approved for any of their recommendations or offers.

If Credit Karma doesn't suit your needs, here's how you can look for another option.

What is your primary reason for seeking an alternative to Credit Karma?

Tips For Choosing A Credit Karma Alternative

Don't know which alternative to choose? Ask yourself the following questions:

  • Which credit bureaus are monitored in the app?
    The three main credit bureaus are Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. Ideally, you should keep track of the three since not all lenders report to the three credit bureaus.

  • Which credit score does the app track?
    Lenders either use FICO Score or VantageScore. However, FICO Score is more commonly used than VantageScore. Most lenders will use your FICO scores to assess your creditworthiness and ability to pay back what you owe.

  • Is identity theft essential?
    The unauthorized use of your identity compromises your credit. Having extra identity theft insurance or additional monitoring features can give that extra layer of protection.

  • Is the price justifiable for the features?
    Free plans offer limited features. But many credit monitoring apps offer discounts for paid plans. You can maximize annual discounts and promos to make plans more affordable.

  • Is credit monitoring only for you or your family?
    A family plan provides better value if you want to extend credit monitoring and identity theft protection to family members.

    Look for the ones with insurance for each member and specialized monitoring for children. This can help with preventing damage to their credit profile, cyberbullying, and unsafe online activities.

Methodology

We selected Credit Karma alternatives that monitored Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. These alternatives also monitor your FICO Score or VantageScore.

Several credit monitoring tools may bundle extra features for additional security. We chose alternatives that may include features like insurance, SSN alerts, dark web alerts, credit report locks, or social media monitoring.

Additionally, these alternatives cost $15–$30 (for one person) or a maximum of $50 (for families). Plans differ by the number of people you can enroll and feature inclusions.

If you can't afford the paid options, we've included free plans with limited credit monitoring.

Bottom Line

You don't have to pay much to monitor your credit effectively. You can maximize free options to do it. Credit Karma already offers basic credit monitoring without fees attached.

However, paid options often include additional features for better credit monitoring and protection. In the long run, paying a few dollars monthly may give you more peace of mind.

If the options in this list aren't enough, you can browse for more comprehensive tools. There are more credit monitoring services with various extra features and plan inclusions.

References

  1. ^ Experian. Identity protection plans, Retrieved 11/30/2023
  2. ^ FICO Score. FICO SCORES ARE USED BY 90% OF TOP LENDERS, Retrieved 11/30/2023
  3. ^ myFICO. FICO Free Plan, Retrieved 01/15/2024
  4. ^ myFICO. Subscription Plans, Retrieved 01/15/2024
  5. ^ Capital One. CreditWise, Retrieved 01/15/2024
  6. ^ Credit Sesame. Isn't Credit Sesame free?, Retrieved 01/15/2024
  7. ^ Credit Sesame. How much do the premium subscription plans cost?, Retrieved 01/15/2024
  8. ^ Aura. Pricing, Retrieved 11/30/2023
  9. ^ ID Watchdog. Identity Theft Product Comparison, Retrieved 12/01/2023
  10. ^ Identity Guard. Plans & Pricing: Identity Guard for Individuals & Families, Retrieved 12/01/2023
  11. ^ Identity Force. ID Protection Products & Coverage, Retrieved 12/05/2023

Write to Alex Mambaje at feedback@creditdonkey.com. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for our latest posts.

Note: This website is made possible through financial relationships with some of the products and services mentioned on this site. We may receive compensation if you shop through links in our content. You do not have to use our links, but you help support CreditDonkey if you do.

Compare:

Build credit and save money. Sign up to get our FREE email newsletter.
Flat Fee Credit Card Processing

Flat Fee Credit Card Processing

Flat-fee credit card processing can be affordable, depending on your business. Read on for the ins and outs of this pricing model.

About CreditDonkey
CreditDonkey is a credit card comparison website. We publish data-driven analysis to help you save money & make savvy decisions.

Editorial Note: Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed on this page are those of the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

†Advertiser Disclosure: Many of the offers that appear on this site are from companies from which CreditDonkey receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). CreditDonkey does not include all companies or all offers that may be available in the marketplace.

*See the card issuer's online application for details about terms and conditions. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. However, all information is presented without warranty. When you click on the "Apply Now" button you can review the terms and conditions on the card issuer's website.

CreditDonkey does not know your individual circumstances and provides information for general educational purposes only. CreditDonkey is not a substitute for, and should not be used as, professional legal, credit or financial advice. You should consult your own professional advisors for such advice.

About Us | Reviews | Deals | Tips | Privacy | Do Not Sell My Info | Terms | Contact Us
(888) 483-4925 | 680 East Colorado Blvd, 2nd Floor | Pasadena, CA 91101
© 2024 CreditDonkey Inc. All Rights Reserved.