August 19, 2024

Best Debt Management Companies


Overwhelmed by debt? The best debt management companies slash interest rates and remove fees. Explore your top options in this article.

What are the best debt management companies?
Here are the top options to choose from:
  1. ACCC as best overall
  2. MMI for 24/7 counseling
  3. Credit.org for low fees
  4. DMCC for financial education
  5. InCharge Debt Solutions for credit card debt
  6. Cambridge for the highest potential savings
  7. Greenpath for student debt
  8. Consolidated Credit for creditor negotiations

A DMP or debt management plan is a 3 to 5-year repayment plan that can help you manage your debts more easily.

Counselors and debt professionals negotiate with creditors to reduce your interest, eliminate penalties and fees, or adjust terms.

But not all debt management companies are equal. In this guide, learn about the top companies and agencies that can help you out.

Which method would you be more likely to use if you were looking to manage your debt?

Top 8 Debt Management Companies

The best debt management companies offer free consultations to help you get started. Be sure to note the fees and the upsides and downsides of each.

What is the most important factor for you when choosing a debt management company?

ACCC: Best Overall

American Consumer Credit Counseling (ACCC) is a leading nonprofit organization offering debt relief options, including debt management. Established in 1991, it can help reduce your interest rates and monthly debt payments by 30-50%.[1]

Aside from DMPs, counselors can also give you advice on budgeting, improving credit, and exploring bankruptcy options.

Fees:[2]
The fees depend on your state. On average, clients pay only $25/mo after setting up their DMP. That said, ACCC can waive your fees if you experience financial hardship.

  • One-time enrollment fee: $39
  • Monthly fee: $7 per account (min. of $7; max. of $70)

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • COA accreditation
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • Available in all 50 states[3]
  • iOS app & Android app
  • There's a cap for the accounts you can enroll in the DMP
  • Limited service hours

Ready to make a call?
You can call ACCC at 800-769-3571 ext. 1912.[4] You can reach them at the following schedule:
  • 09:00AM to 08:00PM ET Monday through Thursday
  • 09:00AM to 06:00PM ET Friday

If you're looking for a team that's available regardless of the time of day, check out this next option.

MMI: for 24/7 Counseling

Money Management International (MMI) is another nonprofit organization on the list, with roots dating back to 1958. Since then, it has helped repay almost $10 billion of debt.

On average, the debt relief company can reduce your interest rates to less than 8%. What's more, clients who have completed their DMP raise their credit scores by 84 points.[5]

You can sign up or call MMI for assistance and counseling anytime. Counselors are available around the clock to help you out.

Fees:[6]
Unlike ACCC, MMI doesn't list its exact fees. However, on average, MMI clients pay:

  • Average setup fee: $33 (max. of $75)
  • Average monthly fee: $25 (max. of $59)

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • FCAA member
  • COA accreditation
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • 24/7 free counseling
  • Unclear fees

How to Contact MMI
You can call MMI at 866-889-9347. They're available 24/7.[7]

Maybe you're on a budget and is looking for the most affordable DMP. Credit.org may be able to help you out.

Credit.Org: for Low Fees

Established in 1974, Credit.org is one of the longest-running organizations offering debt management. Every year, it helps over 25,000 people through its services.[8]

A team of more than 50 financial counselors can assist you in enrolling your debts in a DMP. Additionally, Credit.org has one of the lowest fees, which can be waived if you can't afford them.

Fees:[9]
The monthly fee depends on state regulations. But you can budget the following:

  • One-time setup fee for enrollment: $0–$50
  • Monthly fee: $0–$75

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • COA accreditation
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • Available in all 50 states[10]
  • Limited service hours

Ready to consult?
You can reach out to Credit.org at 844-660-3328 from 08:00AM to 05:00PM PT, Monday through Friday.[11]

Maybe apart from paying off your debts, you want to learn more about how to manage your finances. DMCC may be your best bet.

DMCC: for Financial Education

Debt Management Credit Counseling Corp. (DMCC) is a nonprofit corporation that offers DMPs. Based in Florida, it has paid off over $500 million in debts of over 100,000 clients.

On average, clients pay 8.2% interest rates on their debts through the DMP. That said, DMCC can lessen your debt payments by as much as 24%.[12]

Additionally, DMCC features DMCC University, where you can browse free videos, seminars, workshops, and online courses about financial topics.

Fees:
DMCC does not specify its monthly fees. The set-up fee for their debt management plan ranges from $50 to $100, but military personnel and their families may qualify for a fee waiver.[13]

Pros + Cons:

  • FCAA member
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • Works with the biggest creditors in the US
  • Unclear fees
  • Limited service hours

Ready to make a call?
You can get in touch with DMCC at 954-418-1466.[14] Make sure to call between:
  • 09:00AM to 06:00PM ET Monday through Thursday
  • 09:00AM to 03:00PM Friday ET

Do you only have credit card debts to worry about? InCharge Debt Solutions is the expert to go for.

Incharge Debt Solutions: for Credit Card Debt

InCharge Debt Solutions has helped over a million people since 1997, settling over $3.4 billion in debt.[15]

On average, it can reduce credit card interest to 8.4%. But depending on negotiations, interest rates can go as low as 2%.[16]

That said, InCharge Debt Solutions primarily focuses on credit cards. If you owe other unsecured debts, like personal loans and medical bills, you can ask about them during the consultation.

Fees:[16]
InCharge Debt Solutions doesn't specify its monthly fees. But on average, clients pay $33/mo. The one-time setup fee is $75, though this varies by state.

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • COA accreditation
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • Certifications, awards, and recognition in the industry
  • Limited service hours
  • Mostly covers credit card debts

Ready to get started?
You can reach InCharge Debt Solutions at (800) 565-8953 from:[17]
  • 09:00AM to 10:00PM ET Monday through Friday
  • 09:00AM to 06:00PM ET Saturday

What if saving most of your payments is your main goal for a DMP? Cambridge can help you out.

What type of debt is causing you the most stress?

Cambridge: Highest Potential Savings

Cambridge started in the industry in 1996. On average, its DMP clients lessen the interest rates on their credit cards down to 8%, sometimes up to 0%.

Additionally, you can save as much as 25% of your monthly debt payments. And you can settle debts in as fast as 42 months.[18]

On top of credit cards, your DMP can include the following debts:

  • Unsecured personal loans
  • Personal loans secured by household items, such as furniture, appliances, etc.
  • Past-due balances on telephone bills, cellular phone bills, electric bills, etc.
  • Student loans
  • Collection accounts
  • Lines of credit
  • Disconnected utility bills
  • Medical bills
  • Repossessions (if the items have been resold and an unpaid balance remains)

Tip: Your past due balances can be qualified as long as you no longer reside at the same residence, and the debt is for an old and inactive account.

Fees:[19]
Cambridge doesn't specify its fees, but on average, clients pay:

  • Average initial fee: $40 (max. of $75)
  • Average monthly fee: $30 (max. of $50)

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • FCAA member
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • 24/7 customer service
  • Transparent list of qualified debts
  • Limited service hours

Ready to get started?
Keep in touch with Cambridge counselors by phone at (800) 235-1407 from:[20]
  • 08:00AM to 08:00PM ET Monday through Thursday
  • 08:00AM to 05:00PM ET Friday

Although Cambridge can help with student loans, Greenpath may be the better option if this is the only debt type you need to enroll.

Greenpath: for Student Debt

GreenPath has been in the industry for over 60 years. In 2023 alone, over 9,000 clients have fully settled their debts, paying off over $170 million through GreenPath's DMP.

If you have student debts, you may qualify for GreenPath's SAVE program. GreenPath will assist you in restructuring your student loans to make them more manageable.

The SAVE program reduces your monthly payments based on your income. You could end up paying only 5% of your discretionary income, down from 10%. Plus, with the SAVE program, you won't be charged monthly interest.[21]

Fees:[22]
On average, GreenPath's clients pay:

  • One-time enrollment fee: $35
  • Monthly fee: $28

Fees vary per state regulation. GreenPath can waive fees if you cannot afford them.

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • COA accreditation
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • Limited counseling hours

Ready to call for a consult?
You can contact GreenPath at 844-939-2481 from:[23]
  • 08:00 AM to 10:00PM ET Monday through Thursday
  • 08:00AM to 08:00PM ET Friday
  • 09:00AM to 06:00PM ET Saturday

If you're looking for the experts best at negotiations, check out this next option.

Consolidated Credit: for Creditor Negotiations

Consolidated Credit has been in the industry since 1993. It offers DMPs and has helped over 10 million people since it started.

Additionally, Consolidated Credit works with more than 1,600 creditors and retailers nationwide.[24] If you owe balance to small retailers or creditors who aren't on the list, Consolidated Credit can communicate with them on your behalf.

Supported unsecured debts include most credit cards, collection accounts for unpaid medical bills, and payday loans.

Fees:[25]
Consolidated Credit doesn't specify its fees. However, on average, clients pay $40/mo (max. $79, varies per state).

Pros + Cons:

  • NFCC member
  • FCAA member
  • BBB accreditation (A+ rating)
  • Doesn't specify fees
  • Limited service hours

Get Started with Consolidated Credit
You can reach out to Consolidated Credit at 844-285-9318 from:[26]
  • 08:00 AM to 10:00PM EST Monday through Thursday
  • 08:00AM to 08:00PM EST Friday
  • 09:00AM to 05:00PM EST Saturday

What Is A Debt Management Plan?

A debt management plan (DMP) is a structured repayment plan created by debt management companies or nonprofit agencies.

The plan is tailored to your specific debts and financial capacity, with the goal of helping you pay off your enrolled debts in 3-5 years.

You'll make a single monthly payment, which counselors will distribute to your creditors on your behalf.

Do most creditors accept DMP?
Yes, most creditors accept a DMP to ensure you'll pay back your principal debt. However, creditors aren't obliged to accept. If they don't agree to the terms, you may consider negotiating with your creditor by yourself.

How Do Debt Management Companies Work?

Debt management companies provide you with a personalized debt management plan to help you manage your debts more easily. The process starts with a free consultation.

  1. Free consultation
    You will be matched with a counselor or specialist who will ask about your outstanding debt statements and income. They will qualify for which debts you can enroll.

  2. Personalized debt management plan
    The counselor will create a personalized debt management plan you can afford. The plan may come with a lower monthly payment than your current combined monthly debt payments.

  3. Creditor negotiations
    Experienced counselors and negotiators will negotiate with your qualified creditors. They will send a proposal or correspond with your creditors to enroll your debt in a DMP.

  4. Monthly payments
    You will make monthly payments based on your DMP and initial consultation. Debt management companies will disburse the payments to your creditors.

Note that with DMPs, counselors negotiate to eliminate or reduce interest, penalties, and other fees. Not the principal of your debts. Creditors may also agree to adjust the terms.

That said, DMPs only cover unsecured debts, some including student loans. You can't enroll any debt secured by collateral, like your home and auto loans.

Looking to reduce the principal amount you owe?
Try debt settlement instead. Debt specialists negotiate this amount with creditors.

On the fence about DMPs? Weigh the pros and cons to decide.

Pros And Cons Of Debt Management Plans

Pros:

  • Reduce your interest rates by up to half
  • Eliminate penalties and other fees
  • Get financial advice from experienced counselors
  • Pay off debts faster
  • Focus on one monthly payment only
  • Flat fees (not percentage-based, unlike with debt settlement)
  • May improve your credit over time

Cons:

  • Principal debt remains the same
  • Accounts are closed down
  • Temporary credit impact during enrollment
  • 3–5 year commitment
  • Not all creditors may agree to the DMP
  • Missed payments can end your benefits with the creditors

Does a DMP hurt your credit?
Enrolling your debts in a DMP may temporarily impact your credit. Your accounts will be closed if your creditors agree to the DMP. Fortunately, you can rebuild your credit over time by settling your debts and maintaining a good payment history.

Given the cons of DMPs, how do you know if they are worth it?

Is It Worth Doing A Debt Management Plan?

Debt management plans are beneficial if you want to restructure your debts. By eliminating fees and reducing interest, you can lower the overall cost of your debt in the long run.

Additionally, you can receive valuable advice from experienced counselors. A free consultation allows you to discuss your current financial challenges and explore available means to solve them.

However, while a DMP can reduce other debt-related costs, it does not decrease the original amount you owe. And if you have multiple debts, you will still need to settle them all over the next five years.

Despite this, considering a DMP can be worthwhile, as it helps you pause other accumulating costs related to your debts.

Methodology

There are more agencies and companies offering DMPs, but we've narrowed down this list based on the following:

Fees
All the options in this list are nonprofits dedicated to promoting financial literacy. As a result, they cap their fees, charging less than $100 for a one-time setup fee and even less for monthly fees.

Additionally, these nonprofits are willing to waive fees. If you need help with their fees, they may administer and set up your DMP for free so you can focus on your monthly payments.

Years in the industry
These nonprofits offering DMPs have over 2 decades of experience.

Accreditations
Most options in the list are accredited or members of large organizations and certifying bodies like:

  • Financial Counseling Association of America (FCAA)
  • National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC)
  • Social Current's Council of Accreditation (COA)

These credit counseling agencies and debt management companies are regularly assessed and vetted for credibility, regulatory and state compliance, and service.

Bottom Line

Talking to creditors can be nerve-wracking when you have difficulty paying off your debts. Having professionals to bridge that gap may lessen the stress.

Reputable companies and agencies have solid experience in creditor negotiations. They can negotiate with your previous retailers, banks, or lenders to let you settle your balances with lower interest and adjusted terms.

That said, once you enroll in a DMP, it's best to complete it so you can slowly become debt-free and rebuild your credit over time.

References

  1. ^ ACCC. Need Solutions for Easing Debt Anxiety?, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  2. ^ ACCC. FAQ: What is the cost of the Debt Management Program?, Retrieved 06/03/2024
  3. ^ ACCC. About Us, Retrieved 06/04/2024
  4. ^ ACCC. FAQ: What can I expect from my counseling session?, 06/02/2024
  5. ^ MMI. How Much Can You Save with a Debt Management Plan?, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  6. ^ MMI. What is a debt management plan?, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  7. ^ MMI. Contact Us FAQ: How do I begin?, 06/18/2024
  8. ^ Credit.org. About Credit.org, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  9. ^ Credit.org. Counseling and Education Pricing, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  10. ^ Credit.org. What Can Consumer Credit Counseling Do For You?, Retrieved 06/04/2024
  11. ^ Credit.org. Contact Us, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  12. ^ DMCC. Begin your path to debt freedom today!, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  13. ^ DMCC. Military Personnel, Retrieved 07/31/2024
  14. ^ DMCC. Contact Us, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  15. ^ InCharge Debt Solutions. About Us, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  16. ^ InCharge Debt Solutions. Debt Management Program, Retrieved 05/31/2024
  17. ^ InCharge Debt Solutions. How Can We Help You Today?, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  18. ^ Cambridge. Debt Management Plans, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  19. ^ Cambridge. FAQ: Do you charge fees for your credit counseling and debt management plan services?, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  20. ^ Cambridge. FAQ: What are Cambridge Credit Counseling's credentials?, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  21. ^ GreenPath. SAVE Program - New Lower Monthly Payment Plan, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  22. ^ GreenPath. FAQ: How much does it cost for a debt management program?, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  23. ^ GreenPath. Contact Us, Retrieved 07/28/2024
  24. ^ Consolidated Credit. Creditors We Can Negotiate with On Your Behalf, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  25. ^ Consolidated Credit. Fees, Retrieved 06/02/2024
  26. ^ Consolidated Credit. Contact Us, Retrieved 06/02/2024

Write to Alex Mambaje at feedback@creditdonkey.com. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for our latest posts.


Debt Relief

Save money and build wealth. Sign up to get our FREE email newsletter.

About CreditDonkey
CreditDonkey is a personal finance comparison website. We publish data-driven analysis to help you save money & make savvy decisions.

Editorial Note: Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed on this page are those of the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

†Advertiser Disclosure: Many of the offers that appear on this site are from companies from which CreditDonkey receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). CreditDonkey does not include all companies or all offers that may be available in the marketplace.

*See the card issuer's online application for details about terms and conditions. Reasonable efforts are made to maintain accurate information. However, all information is presented without warranty. When you click on the "Apply Now" button you can review the terms and conditions on the card issuer's website.

CreditDonkey does not know your individual circumstances and provides information for general educational purposes only. CreditDonkey is not a substitute for, and should not be used as, professional legal, credit or financial advice. You should consult your own professional advisors for such advice.

About Us | Reviews | Deals | Tips | Privacy | Do Not Sell My Info | Terms | Contact Us
(888) 483-4925 | 680 East Colorado Blvd, 2nd Floor | Pasadena, CA 91101
© 2024 CreditDonkey Inc. All Rights Reserved.